Help me with a photo decision? 56k WARNED!!!

[SMS 1]

I know this isn't a photography forum but I figured you guys might have an opinion to help me decide so here goes . . .




Posted by Canon Fan . . .

This is another shot of Crazy Horse Memorial monument in South Dakota that I took on recent vacation. Shot in RAW and I now have two versions converted and in printable 8x10" form. However I can't decide which one I like better, or at all. Personally I like them both but thought I'd bring them to you to help me out.

What do you think?

http://aurigenmedia.com/SD/ch3BW.jpg

Or . . .

http://aurigenmedia.com/SD/ch3C.jpg

Kind of a bummer to shrink/compress these though they look SO much better in RAW or TIFF format, the .jpg conversion just makes them really soft!

[GTSLOW]

I like the color one!~

[Zkid14]

I vote colored

[Lash]

color :shades

[CruxGNZ]

It might just be the brightness of the photos (or my monitor), but the color photo looks the best.

!M!

[Cryptic]

color

and incidently... I am getting rid of that damn minimum 10 character post rule

[Cryptic]

bla

[SMS 1]

:shades

[Prince Valiant]

colour

^how french is that?

[Al]

Color!

They have made some progress since I last saw a photo.

[jbiscuit]

yeah I haven't seen a Crazy Horse shot in years either....the color one is better :thumbsup

[Silver350]

I kind of like the black and white. My opinion is that I can see the face better with it being darker because of the shadow. Also to me the texture of the rock stands out more to me. Either picture is nice I just seem to be liking more and more of the Black and white stuff these days.

[SMS 1]

Thanks for the replies guys. In the end I have now test printed both. I still think each has it's place and am not sure which one I personally like better. This one is still up for debate!